I suspect what this adoptee is dealing with is not all that unusual. Today’s story –
Have any other adoptees here experienced an increased difficulty in parting with meaningful material items? I’m in my late 30s and still have my childhood blanket and stuffed animal. The area rug from our living room when I was growing up that we called my dancing rug. I was devastated when my adoptive dad got rid of it in my twenties without offering it to me first. Those items seem to make sense as being emotionally important but I guess what I’m really asking about is other objects. For example, I have a 2007 Honda Accord that I’ve had since she only had driven 11 mi. I’m close to 190,000 now. I am dreading the day we really start to discuss replacing it. It feels like I’m abandoning it after a lifetime of taking care of me. It’s not missing it, it’s the abandoning it that I struggle with. I know that it’s only a car in my logical brain but when the day comes to leave her at the dealer, I’m going to feel like the worst person alive. I’m not talking about hoarding at all. I’m talking about specific items with a large sentimental value. This isn’t about keeping trinkets or large amounts of items, it’s about attaching an emotional connection to a less traditional personal item, like a vehicle or piece of furniture.
blogger’s note – We have a 2007 Volvo Cross-Country Stationwagon that has spent too much time at our mechanic’s. Hopefully, this last fix is more lasting. We also have a 2005 Suburban that we inherited from my deceased in-law’s. We have less trouble with that one. None of it is about attachment but rather finances.
One adoptee realizes – Oh snap, I think you may have opened a door I’ve never considered before. I have trouble getting rid of things like this as well. It’s the “took care of me part” sigh.
And another notes – I turned 30 this year and still sleep with my blankie. It’s literally falling apart but I have to have it.
One who grew up in kinship care notes – I am 31 and mine is too. I keep mine in a pillowcase to protect it. I hope, if you aren’t, then maybe it might help preserve it for you longer. Mine is just little shreds of fabric basically. It was all I had for a long time for what got to come with me.
Yet another adoptee shares – My adoptive mom threw out my blanket when I was 18, I’m still extremely sad about it (I’m 32 now). She claims “it was the size of a toonie” (slang for a two-dollar coin) but my brain remembers everything and it was still a normal size lovely blanket. I miss it so much.
Yet another adoptee says – I am the opposite, I place partial blame for this on the family that adopted me, as nearly every adult I grew up with is a hoarder. I keep next to nothing, I have a minimalist apartment, and frequently worry that because it is small, it will look cluttered. I have had conversations with my adoptive mother, where she acknowledges that she is a hoarder and she has no plans to change, so when she dies, her 4 bedroom house with a basement full of boxes of “momentos” will be left for me to clean and dig through. And how anyone can do that to their child is beyond my comprehension.
The original poster asks a question – what about big items? I actually don’t really have that many trinkets but it’s more about these big ticket items that have been with me for a long long time like my car. Do you just not form attachment to those types of items? I’m just trying to figure out how other people experience these emotions, if at all.
This is her reply – I have never felt attached to something in a way that it would hurt me if it weren’t there. If I have the opportunity to drive a safer, newer vehicle, I will always choose that as I have had to push some of my cars off 4 lane highways. If I have the opportunity to replace furniture that I know will be more comfortable or better on my body (like a mattress) I will save to be able to do that and discard the old one as soon as possible.
A mom who lost one of her children to adoption notes – I struggle with letting material things go – I lost one of my children to forced adoption. I have my other 3. I still see him, thankfully his adoptive mum is supportive and encourages his relationship with us. Anyway, I have kept everything I had bought him – a crib, changing mat, wardrobes of clothes etc. I gave it to his adoptive parents, so he would still get use of them but asked that they be returned to me once he had outgrown them. Thankfully, they respected my wishes. It’s all packed away in boxes under a bed in my house. I have a lot of paperwork from the forced adoption and I can’t look at it – I find it too triggering but I’m scared to part with it. What if he wants to see it when he’s older? It’s in boxes all over the house as there’s that much of it.
Yet another older adoptee admits – I’m not really a collector of things, I prefer not to have a lot of stuff but a few certain things I can’t part with. I still have things from childhood and I’m 58.
I found this one very sad – When I was a kid, if my parents got us anything (me and my 2 not-adopted siblings) I always got “the defective one”. This happened so many times that it became a joke that still happens to this day. Just a few months ago, my family ordered take out and when it arrived, there was nothing for me, because they forgot to ask me. My adoptive dad joked that I got the defective one again. It’s not the most hilarious joke, even when I tell it. It shouldn’t be a thing. My childhood Little Pony toy was shaved and given to the dog as a chew toy. My favorite pair of shoes that I bought with my own money from working after school jobs were thrown out by my adoptive mom because they were too ratty, in her opinion. I wonder if any of this has caused me to continue to be hanging onto things for so long now.
One adoptee responds to an insensitive remark with this truth – I am going to challenge you to flip that. Imagine being given away because you didn’t spark joy. Because for a lot of us… that is how we feel.
The original poster thanked one adoptee by saying – I needed help to advocate for myself with some of these responses from adoptive parents (blogger’s note – I have chosen NOT to share those here). In a post about abandonment and sentiment, I don’t really need to hear from the purchasers of the abandoned, who literally depended on our disposal (nice word choice there) and gained from it.
From a trans-racial adoptee – Not just meaningful items, but possessions in general. Although meaningful items are much harder. My issues were absolutely compounded by my adoptive mother often going through my room and giving away my things without my knowledge, much less consent. And never mind my adoptive parents giving away multiple pets without telling me either. So if an item was gifted to me, or has any sort of good memory attached to it, I have difficulty getting rid or disposing of it in any way.
Another trans-racial adoptee adds – I can never part with anything. I hate change. I get very attached to things.
Yet another has an odd combination of traits – I’m a minimalist but am very tied to items with sentimental value. It can be challenging.